Our Products

Our happy goats make some amazing products.  Please scroll down to learn more about our delicious cheeses and yogurt as well as our popular goats’ milk soaps and other skin care products. Purchase a Gift Card Here

Currently, we are not able to ship our cheeses and yogurt, but we can send our soaps and lotions just about anywhere in the United States.  We’re also happy to prepare a gift basket and note if you’d like to share our products with others.

Farm to Table

“Best Goat Cheese in the USA” – American Cheese Society 2005, 2008, 2009.  “Best Sheep Cheese” – American Cheese Society 2013. 

Delicious cheese & yogurt from happy goats…and cows! Note:  we source all of our cow’s milk from Ty Llwyd Farm in Jamesport, NY.

Dairy products available seasonally and must be purchased in-store!

Fresh Cheese

catapano dairy farm feta



Traditional crumbly white cheese, made from goat milk. Unlike anything you can buy in the grocery store!

Purchase in-store only. 

catapano dairy farm ricotta



Soft, rich ricotta made from goat milk.

Purchase in-store only. 

catapano dairy farm Soft Chevre with leaves

Soft Chevre

$12.50 – $12.75

Our signature, award-winning, creamy fresh goat cheese. Available in several flavors, including herb, honey and mango habanero.

Purchase in-store only. 

Aged Cheese

Chevre goat cheese

NoFo Jack


Mild, nutty Monterrey Jack style cheese made from happy North Fork cows’ milk. Our son Liam’s favorite cheese!

Purchase in-store only. 

catapano dairy farm cheese creamy sheep

Peconic Bel


Smooth Bel Paese style cheese, made with a mixture of cow and goat milk. Mild, buttery, semi-soft, aged for 6-8 weeks.

Purchase in-store only. 

catapano dairy farm summer cloud cheese

Summer Cloud


Caerphilly style goat cheese – white, crumbly, with a tang of lemon.

Purchase in-store only. 

Premium Goat Milk Bath & Body Products

Our skincare line is made with the finest ingredients available, natural skin-loving botanicals, and, of course, our very own goat milk. 


Take a memory from your favorite farm home with you or send it to a friend!